Why can't our group just play without keeping score?
Three men in my village started a Tuesday backgammon game, just for the pleasure of it. By the third month, one kept a notebook of wins. By the sixth, they argued about handicaps like tax auditors. The dice were still dice. The joy had moved to a filing cabinet. This is what happens when people who care about each other start caring, without noticing, about getting better at the one thing that was never supposed to have a 'better.' Improvement doesn't announce itself. It just quietly starts keeping the minutes of the meeting. If your group can name every player's stats but not the last time you all laughed mid-game, you have this. It is common, it is fixable, and no one has to be blamed for bringing the notebook.
You didn't gain a hobby together — you built a second job with no pay and worse meetings. The fix isn't trying harder to relax. Agree, out loud, as a group, that one shared activity stays permanently unmeasured: no scores, no streaks, no 'getting better.' Just the doing, witnessed by each other.
What changes unlock by starting
- The group can tell, in the moment, when play has quietly turned into training
- Sessions end in laughter or complaint about the rules, not progress reports
- People stop privately comparing themselves to the others in the room
- At least one activity in the group's life stays permanently useless, and everyone protects it