Library›Concepts›Libertarian justice — property and freedom
Concepts
Philosophical

Libertarian justice — property and freedom

Libertarian justice, as articulated by Nozick and others, holds that justice is a matter of process rather than outcome — that a distribution is just if it arose from free exchange among consenting persons, regardless of how unequal the result. On this view, redistribution is a form of theft; the only legitimate role of the state is to protect property and enforce contracts. The framework has significant internal consistency and correctly identifies the importance of individual liberty; its difficulty is that it treats initial property distributions as though they were uncontaminated by historical injustice — which, for most real economies, they are not.

Juana
Juana
Online
The coach is replying…
306 concepts
Access to Knowledge as Economic FreedomAutonomy as Property: The Right to One's Own TimeAutonomy in Vocation and LaborAutonomy Through Economic Self-SufficiencyBodily Autonomy and the Right to StudyCensorship as Property ViolationCommunity and Voluntary Association in Intellectual LifeCompulsory Obedience as Property TheftConscience as Inalienable PropertyConscience as Inviolable PropertyConsent and Authority in Knowledge ExchangeConsent and Authority in Knowledge ProductionConsent and Epistemic CoercionConsent and Knowledge ProductionConsent and the Refusal of Forced VowsConsent and Voluntary Association in Knowledge CommunitiesConsent as Revocable and ConditionalConsent as the Boundary of Legitimate AuthorityConsent as the Foundation of AuthorityConsent Over Obedience in Authority RelationsConsent, Coercion, and Intellectual ObedienceContractual Autonomy Against Coerced VowsCritique as Fundamental LibertyCritique as Property of the DispossessedCritique of Intellectual ConscriptionCultural Inheritance as Common PropertyCultural Inheritance as Contested PropertyDecentralized Authority and Distributed Intellectual PowerDefense Against Institutional AppropriationDefensive Knowledge Against Institutional PowerDefensive Scholarship Against PowerDialogue and Intellectual EqualsDignity as Non-Negotiable Foundation of RightsDiscourse as Property and PowerDissent as Property in Truth-ClaimsEarned Autonomy Through Intellectual LaborEconomic Autonomy Through Creative WorkEconomic Autonomy Through KnowledgeEconomic Independence and Creative FreedomEconomic Independence as Intellectual PreconditionEconomic Independence Through AuthorshipEconomic Independence Through Intellectual LaborEconomic Independence Through Intellectual WorkEconomic Independence Through Knowledge WorkEducation as Economic EnfranchisementEducation as Investment in Self-OwnershipEducation as Liberation Versus Education as ControlEducation as Libertarian Right and ResourceEpistemic Authority and Property RightsEpistemic Autonomy and DissentEpistemic Freedom and Knowledge AccessEpistemic Justice and Equal Intellectual WorthEpistemic Justice and Equal StandingEpistemic Justice and Fair Knowledge ExchangeEpistemic Justice and Intellectual LegitimacyEpistemic Justice and Knowledge OwnershipEpistemic Justice and Property ClaimsEpistemic Justice and Property RightsEpistemic Justice: The Right to Speak as a KnowerEpistemic Resistance and Intellectual RefusalEpistemic Sovereignty and Knowledge RightsFreedom as Capacity, Not Mere Absence of ConstraintFreedom from Doctrinal MonopolyFreedom from Forced Labor of VoiceFreedom from Institutional CensorshipFreedom from Intellectual ConscriptionFreedom from Intellectual ServitudeFreedom of Conscience Against AuthorityFreedom of Conscience Against Institutional PowerFreedom of Conscience Against Religious AuthorityFreedom of Conscience and InquiryFreedom of Conscience as Economic RightFreedom of Conscience as Inviolable PropertyFreedom of Conscience as Property in BeliefFreedom of Conscience as Property RightFreedom of Inquiry as Economic RightFreedom of Inquiry Without Economic CoercionFreedom of Inquiry Without PermissionFreedom of Vocation and Occupational ChoiceFreedom Through Self-Education and StudyGender and Property Rights EqualityGender and Property: Women's Economic PersonhoodGender as Arbitrary Basis for ExclusionGender as Artificial Property RestrictionGender as Barrier to Property RecognitionGender, Property Rights, and Intellectual ExclusionGendered Exclusion as Economic DispossessionGendered Property DispossessionGendered Property Dispossession and Rights RecoveryIdentity as Inalienable PropertyIdentity as Intellectual PropertyIdentity as Non-Transferable PropertyIdentity Autonomy and the Right to Self-DefinitionInheritance and Responsibility: The Legacy of ThoughtInheritance of Intellectual CapitalInstitutional Accountability and AnswerabilityInstitutional Capture and the Abuse of AuthorityInstitutional Critique and Intellectual RightsInstitutional Critique as a Liberty PracticeInstitutional Critique as Freedom PracticeInstitutional Critique as Intellectual FreedomInstitutional Critique as Property DefenseInstitutional Exit and Principled RetreatInstitutional Exit as Ultimate Property RightInstitutional Independence as Freedom PrerequisiteInstitutional Limits on Personal FreedomInstitutional Neutrality and Intellectual FreedomInstitutional Parasitism on Intellectual LaborInstitutional Resistance and ExitInstitutional Resistance to Dissent: Power's Property ClaimsInstitutional Resistance to Personal SovereigntyInstitutional Resistance Without ExitIntellectual Commons as Voluntary Association, Not CoercionIntellectual Labor and Fair CompensationIntellectual Labor and Just CompensationIntellectual Labor as Legitimate WorkIntellectual Legacy as Transgenerational PropertyIntellectual Lineage as Inherited PropertyIntellectual Property as Moral RightIntellectual Property as Personal FreedomIntellectual Property as Personal LibertyIntellectual Property as Personal RightIntellectual Property as Personal SovereigntyIntellectual Property as Sacred LaborIntellectual Property as Sacred RightIntellectual Property as Self-OwnershipIntellectual Property as Self-SovereigntyIntersectional Oppression and Compound InjusticeIntersectional Oppression and Compounded UnfreedomIntersectional Property Claims and Compounded DispossessionIntersectional Property RightsJustice as Recognition of Full PersonhoodJustice as Recognition of Intellectual RightsJustice as Recognition of Unequal Starting PointsJustice Without Redistribution: Merit, Recognition, and Fair ExchangeKnowledge as Collective Heritage and Individual PropertyKnowledge as Distributed Property and CommonsKnowledge as Earned PropertyKnowledge as Economic SovereigntyKnowledge as Emancipatory PracticeKnowledge as Emancipatory PropertyKnowledge as Liberating PropertyKnowledge as Liberation and PropertyKnowledge as Liberatory PropertyKnowledge as Libertarian ResistanceKnowledge as Private Property in Patriarchal SystemsKnowledge as Property DefenseKnowledge Barriers and Unjust DistributionKnowledge Commons and Intellectual CirculationKnowledge Commons and the Limits of EnclosureKnowledge Commons and the Public GoodKnowledge Enclosure and Intellectual CommonsKnowledge Exchange Without CommodificationKnowledge Work and Economic JusticeLegacy and Intellectual InheritanceLegacy and Posthumous Property RightsLegacy and Vindication as Historical JusticeLiteracy and Access as Justice FoundationsMarginality as Intellectual AdvantageOwnership of One's Identity and ExpressionOwnership of One's Time and LaborPatronage and Hidden CoercionPatronage as Alternative to Wage DependencePatronage as Voluntary Exchange, Not ServitudePersonal Identity and Freedom of ThoughtPrivacy and the Sovereignty of Inner LifeProperty in One's Labor Against ExploitationProperty in One's Labor and Creative OutputProperty in One's Own Story and IdentityReclaiming Voice as Reclaiming PropertyRecognition and the Market of Intellectual ValueRedress and the Right to Defend Your ReputationRefusal as a Form of Property ProtectionRefusal as a Property RightRefusal as Economic FreedomRefuse and Resistance: Strategic Non-ComplianceRefusing Forced Renunciation of SelfRemedial Justice for Intellectual TheftResistance Through Writing and AuthorshipResistance to Intellectual ConscriptionResistance to Intellectual EnclosureResistance to Symbolic AppropriationRhetorical Autonomy and Libertarian SpeechRights Defense Through Articulate TestimonyRights of Women as Thinking AgentsSanctuary as Negotiated AutonomySelf-Defense Against Epistemic ViolenceSelf-Determined Religious PracticeSelf-Education as Liberation and ResistanceSelf-Education as Property ReclamationSelf-Ownership Through Intellectual LaborSelf-Ownership Through VocationSilence as Sovereign ResistanceSolitude as Political RightSovereignty of Conscience in Property ClaimsStrategic Retreat and the Limits of ResistanceTestimony and Epistemic AuthorityTestimony as Property Claim and Act of JusticeTextual Authority and Interpretive SovereigntyThe Argument From Silence and ExclusionThe Authority of Personal Experience and ObservationThe Authority of Self-Directed StudyThe Autonomy of Creative LaborThe Autonomy of the Inner SelfThe Boundary Between Public Duty and Private SovereigntyThe Burden of Respectability and PermissionThe Commons of Ideas and Shared IntellectThe Commons of Ideas Versus Institutional MonopoliesThe Commons of Knowledge and Its LimitsThe Commons of Knowledge and LearningThe Commons of Language and CultureThe Commons of Language and LearningThe Commons of Learning and Shared InquiryThe Commons of Shared Intellectual HeritageThe Communal Nature of Intellectual GoodsThe Conscience Exemption FrameworkThe Convent as Counter-Institution: Alternative StructuresThe Convent as Refuge and ContradictionThe Convent as Voluntary AssociationThe Convent as Voluntary RefugeThe Cost of Intellectual ConformityThe Costs of Conformity and Coerced SilenceThe Defense Against Censorship as Property DefenseThe Defense of Curiosity as RightThe Defense of Dissent as Intellectual Property RightThe Dignity of Autonomous LaborThe Dignity of Intellectual DissentThe Dignity of Intellectual LaborThe Dignity of Intellectual RefusalThe Dignity of Self-Directed WorkThe Duty of Conscience Over ObedienceThe Economics of Cultural ProductionThe Economics of Epistemic InjusticeThe Economics of Exclusion and Artificial ScarcityThe Economics of Gender and Excluded PersonsThe Economics of Unpaid Intellectual LaborThe Epistemic Right to Question AuthorityThe Freedom to Document and Publish One's ThoughtThe Gendered Seizure of Intellectual PropertyThe Hierarchy of Duties: Conscience Above CommandThe Identity-Property NexusThe Intellectual Commons vs. Institutional MonopolyThe Knowledge Commons vs. EnclosureThe Knowledge Economy and Individual RightsThe Library as Intellectual Commons and Private RightThe Paradox of Refuge: Safety Through LimitationThe Penalty of Silence as Property ConfiscationThe Personal Library as SanctuaryThe Privatization of ConscienceThe Problem of Coercive VirtueThe Question of Who Owns Your QuestionsThe Restoration of Intellectual Legacy as JusticeThe Right to Complexity and ContradictionThe Right to Defend One's Own MindThe Right to Defend Your Own Authority and CredibilityThe Right to Disobey Unjust AuthorityThe Right to Dissent Within InstitutionsThe Right to Education as Property FreedomThe Right to Institutional Exit and DissociationThe Right to Know and StudyThe Right to Learn as Foundational LibertyThe Right to Learn as Political FreedomThe Right to Learn as Property FreedomThe Right to Learn Without PermissionThe Right to Petition and Be HeardThe Right to Philosophical InquiryThe Right to Productive SolitudeThe Right to Public Intellectual LaborThe Right to Public Voice and ExpressionThe Right to Redefine Your Own IdentityThe Right to Refusal and ConscienceThe Right to Refuse Coercive DutyThe Right to Refuse Enforced IdentityThe Right to Refuse Institutional CoercionThe Right to Refuse Institutional DemandsThe Right to Refuse Institutional SilenceThe Right to Refuse Intellectual LaborThe Right to Refuse ObedienceThe Right to Refuse Unwanted Work and VocationThe Right to Self-Definition Against Imposed IdentityThe Right to Self-Definition and IdentityThe Right to Self-Directed InquiryThe Right to Self-EducationThe Right to Self-Education and AutodidacticismThe Sovereignty of Intellectual LaborThe Tyranny of Compulsory SilenceThe Tyranny of Domestic EnclosureThe Tyranny of Imposed IgnoranceThe Tyranny of Imposed PurposeThe Tyranny of Institutional Monopoly on TruthThe Tyranny of Role PrescriptionTransgressive Knowledge and the Right to InquiryTransgressive Reading as Intellectual PropertyTruth-Seeking as a Property Right and DutyTruth-Telling as a Property and Freedom RightTruth-Telling as Liberation PracticeVoluntary Association Against Coercive HierarchyVoluntary Association and Intellectual CommunityVoluntary Association Beyond Prescribed RolesVoluntary Association in Intellectual CommunityVoluntary Association Over Coerced CommunityVoluntary Association Over Coercive CommunityVoluntary Association Over Coercive HierarchyVoluntary Association Over Compelled ObedienceWomen's Intellectual Property and Gender JusticeWriting as Claim and Inheritance